Husserl’s Phenomenology and Leadership Sensemaking: Learning to See Before We Decide

Husserl’s Phenomenology and Leadership Sensemaking: Learning to See Before We Decide

How leaders can deepen awareness, question assumptions and make wiser decisions in complexity

Leadership is often seen as the ability to make decisions, communicate a vision and mobilise people towards a shared purpose. Yet, beneath these visible activities lies a more fundamental process: how leaders make sense of what is happening.

Two leaders can encounter the same situation and arrive at very different conclusions. One sees resistance; another sees legitimate concern. One interprets silence as agreement; another recognises uncertainty or fear. One views a crisis as a threat to be contained; another sees an opportunity to question assumptions and create a new direction.

The difference is not necessarily the information available to them. It may lie in how they experience, interpret and give meaning to that information.

This is where the philosophy of Edmund Husserl, widely regarded as the founder of phenomenology, offers a valuable perspective on leadership.

Edmund Husserl’s phenomenology is the philosophical study of lived experience and how things appear to human consciousness. It seeks to understand the essential structures of experience by examining phenomena as they are experienced, rather than explaining them through prior assumptions, theories or interpretations. Its central principle is “Back to the things themselves” (Zu den Sachen selbst).

Three key ideas underpin Husserl’s phenomenology:

  • i. Intentionality: Consciousness is always consciousness of something; our experience is directed towards objects, people, events or ideas.
  • ii. Epoché (bracketing): Temporarily suspend taken-for-granted assumptions and judgements to attend more openly to experience.
  • iii. Essences: Explore the essential structures and meanings of experiences through careful reflection on how they are lived.

In essence, phenomenology invites us to set aside what we think we already know and attend carefully to how we actually experience and make sense of the world.

Husserl invites us to investigate experience carefully rather than accept our habitual interpretations as unquestionable truths. His work does not provide a leadership model or a ready-made decision-making framework. Nevertheless, its central ideas offer a philosophical foundation for developing more reflective, curious and discerning leaders.

Phenomenology invites us to ask a deeper question: Before deciding what a situation means and what we should do about it, how do we come to experience it in the way we do?

1. Leadership begins before the decision

Consider a leadership team that has missed its performance targets for three consecutive quarters.

The chief executive interprets the situation as a failure of accountability. The finance director sees an unrealistic strategy. The human resources director notices exhaustion and declining morale. The operations director believes that the organisation’s processes have become too cumbersome.

All four may be describing genuine aspects of the situation. Yet each is also making sense of the situation through a particular perspective, shaped by professional experience, responsibilities, expectations and assumptions.

The chief executive may respond by tightening performance controls. The finance director may recommend revising the strategy. The human resources director may advocate staff support, while the operations director proposes process redesign. Each intervention follows from a particular interpretation of what is happening.

The question Husserl would ask is: how does the situation become meaningful to us in the first place?

Leadership sensemaking therefore involves more than collecting information and analysing facts. It concerns how people notice events, interpret them, construct meaning and act on that meaning. Husserl invites us to examine the structures of experience through which the world appears meaningful. Leaders are therefore encouraged to move beyond asking, “What is happening?” to also ask, “How am I experiencing this situation, and how might that shape what I believe is happening?”

2. Intentionality: we do not experience situations neutrally

One of Husserl’s central ideas is intentionality: consciousness is always directed towards something. We perceive, remember, anticipate, fear or desire something. Our experience is not simply a collection of neutral data; things appear to us in particular ways.

A colleague’s silence, for example, may appear to us as agreement, indifference, defiance or anxiety.

The observable behaviour may be the same. Its meaning differs.

A leadership example: interpreting silence

A director presents a proposed organisational restructuring. Nobody objects during the meeting.

The director concludes that the team supports the proposal and begins implementation.

Two weeks later, implementation stalls. Several managers privately reveal that they had serious reservations but did not feel able to express them.

What went wrong?

The director did not necessarily fail to observe the silence. The problem was how the silence was interpreted. Silence was experienced as agreement rather than as an ambiguous social signal.

A phenomenologically informed leader would become curious about the experience of the meeting itself:

  • a. What did I notice when nobody responded?
  • b. What did the silence mean to me?
  • c. What assumptions did I make about agreement and disagreement?
  • d. How might others have experienced the same meeting?
  • e. What conditions made it easier or harder for people to speak?

The leader might then introduce a different practice: explicitly invite dissenting perspectives, ask what concerns have not yet been voiced, and distinguish genuine commitment from the absence of objection.

Leadership lesson: What we experience is not identical to what the experience means, and what it means to us is not necessarily what it means to others.

3. Epoché: suspending judgement long enough to see differently

Husserl’s concept of epoché involves suspending or bracketing our ordinary assumptions about the world so that we can examine experience more carefully.

It does not require leaders to abandon judgement, deny facts or postpone every decision. Rather, it invites them to recognise when an interpretation has become so automatic that alternative explanations are no longer considered.

In leadership, this is particularly important because experience and authority can reinforce one another. The more senior a leader becomes, the more readily others may accept the leader’s interpretation, even when it is incomplete.

A leadership example: the “resistant” team

A leadership team repeatedly fails to implement a new digital system. The project sponsor describes the team as resistant to change.

This explanation seems plausible. It also directs attention towards changing employees’ attitudes.

But what if the team is experiencing something different?

Perhaps the system was introduced without sufficient consultation. Perhaps staff are managing incompatible systems. Perhaps training has been inadequate. Perhaps the new system improves reporting for senior management while increasing the administrative burden on frontline employees.

Suspending the initial judgement does not mean that resistance is impossible. It means that resistance is a hypothesis to investigate, not a conclusion that ends inquiry.

The leader can ask:

  • a. What evidence supports my interpretation?
  • b. What evidence might challenge it?
  • c. How do different groups experience the change?
  • d. What constraints are visible to employees but less visible to me?
  • e. What might I learn if I temporarily stopped describing the problem as resistance?

The outcome may still be a need for behavioural change. But the intervention will be better informed if the leader first understands the situation from several perspectives.

Phenomenological inquiry therefore provides a discipline of intellectual humility. It helps leaders distinguish what they have observed from what they have inferred.

4. The lifeworld: leadership takes place within worlds of taken-for-granted meaning

Husserl also developed the concept of the lifeworld, the everyday world of lived experience that provides the background for our perceptions, assumptions and practical activities.

We usually act within this world without having to explain its meanings to ourselves. We know how meetings work, what authority implies, what counts as appropriate behaviour and which questions are considered acceptable.

Organisations also develop lifeworlds: shared habits, assumptions, stories and expectations that shape what people consider normal.

Some are formally expressed in policies and values. Others remain largely unspoken.

Consider an organisation that publicly encourages innovation but has a history of punishing failed experiments.

Its formal message is, “Take risks and learn.”

Its lived message may be, “Do not make a mistake that could damage your reputation.”

Employees may appear cautious or uncreative, not because they lack innovative capacity, but because their everyday experience has taught them that experimentation is unsafe.

A leadership example: the gap between espoused values and lived reality

A newly appointed Provost in a higher education institution wants to encourage interdisciplinary collaboration.

The institutional strategy celebrates collaboration. Yet academic departments compete for funding, promotion criteria reward individual achievement, and workload models leave little time for joint projects.

The Provost initially interprets the lack of collaboration as a cultural problem.

A deeper inquiry examines how the institution’s actual practices shape the meaning of collaboration for its members.

The Provost asks:

  • a. What does collaboration mean in the daily experience of academics?
  • b. What behaviours are rewarded, despite the language of our strategy?
  • c. Which assumptions about expertise, ownership and status remain unexamined?
  • d. What would need to change for collaboration to become a credible and worthwhile activity?

This inquiry may lead to changes in incentives, workload allocation, decision-making and resource sharing rather than another communication campaign.

The lifeworld concept reminds leaders that organisational culture is not simply what people say they believe. It is also the background of meanings through which they experience their work and decide what is sensible, possible and safe.

5. Intersubjectivity: leadership requires understanding worlds other than our own

Husserl explored how we experience other people as subjects who have their own perspectives and experiences. We inhabit a world with others, but we do not experience that world identically.

This insight has profound implications for leadership.

Leaders often assume that their intentions are sufficiently clear, that their priorities are self-evident or that others interpret events in much the same way they do.

Yet the same organisational decision can have different meanings for different people.

A restructuring may represent strategic renewal to the executive team, uncertainty about employment to staff, disruption to clients and an opportunity for innovation to external partners.

These interpretations are not merely communication errors. They may arise from genuinely different positions, responsibilities, histories and interests.

A leadership example: conflicting definitions of success

A nursing-home leadership team is asked to improve operational efficiency.

The finance manager focuses on cost control. The clinical lead emphasises quality of care. The facilities manager is concerned about staffing and maintenance. The director is accountable for the organisation’s long-term viability.

Each is working towards a legitimate objective, but their definitions of efficiency may conflict.

A phenomenologically informed leader does not begin by deciding which perspective is correct. The leader creates conditions for each person to explain what success means from their position and how they experience the constraints facing the others.

Questions might include:

  • a. What does a successful outcome mean from your perspective?
  • b. What are you most concerned about losing?
  • c. What do you understand about the pressures facing your colleagues?
  • d. Where do our priorities genuinely conflict?
  • e. What shared purpose could help us negotiate these differences?

This does not imply that every perspective is equally accurate or that all interests can be reconciled. It means that better collective judgement requires understanding how different people experience the situation before imposing a single interpretation.

Intersubjectivity is therefore a foundation for relational leadership: the ability to work with differences in experience and meaning without prematurely reducing them to agreement or disagreement.

6. Embodiment: the body participates in how leaders make sense

Husserl’s work evolved over time. Later developments in phenomenology also explored the lived body as our embodied standpoint in the world. Our experience is not purely intellectual; perception and meaning are also shaped by bodily capacities and sensations.

For leadership, this opens an important avenue of reflection.

A leader may notice a tightening in the chest before a difficult conversation, a feeling of relief when a particular proposal is withdrawn, or an impulse to interrupt when challenged.

These sensations do not tell the leader automatically what is true. They provide experiences that can be examined alongside thoughts, emotions, behaviour and contextual evidence.

A leadership example: the leader who cannot tolerate disagreement

A chief executive prides herself on being open to challenge. Yet she notices that whenever a senior colleague questions her proposal, she becomes tense, speaks more quickly and begins defending her position.

She initially explains her response as a need to correct inaccurate information.

Through reflection, she begins to recognise the sequence:

  1. A colleague challenges her proposal.
  2. She experiences bodily tension and a sense of threat.
  3. She interprets the challenge as questioning her competence.
  4. She responds defensively.
  5. The colleague becomes more cautious about challenging her in future.

The leader begins practising a pause before responding. She notices her physical reactions, distinguishes the challenge to an idea from a judgement of her worth, and asks the colleague to elaborate.

Over time, the interaction becomes a source of learning rather than a threat to authority.

This is not a claim that bodily sensations reveal hidden truths. Rather, they can help leaders notice how their habitual ways of experiencing a situation influence their interpretations and actions.

7. From phenomenology to leadership action: an ongoing inquiry

Phenomenology is not a substitute for organisational analysis, evidence-based decision-making or ethical judgement. Its value lies in deepening the quality of attention through which leaders interpret and respond to situations.

I propose a process of leadership inquiry and learning informed by Husserl’s phenomenology:

Attend → Describe → Question → Explore → Act → Reflect

Professional Process Infographic: Six Steps for Success. 1 Attend—Observational and mindfulness: Notice details, be present, gather information. 2 Describe—Documentation and objectivity: Write observations, record facts, note details without judgment. 3 Question—Inquiry and curiosity: Ask why, how, and what; identify gaps and formulate hypotheses. 4 Explore—Research and option seeking: Gather data, investigate solutions, generate ideas, test theories. 5 Act—Implementation and execution: Apply learnings, carry out a plan, take decisive steps. 6 Reflect—Evaluation and analysis: Review outcomes, assess performance, learn from experience, identify areas for improvement.

1. Attend (Observation & Mindfulness): Notice what is happening, including bodily responses, emotions, language, behaviour and context.

2. Describe (Objective Description without judgement): Distinguish observable events from the meanings and explanations you have attached to them.

3. Question (Inquiry & Curiosity): Suspend premature conclusions and examine the assumptions shaping your interpretation.

4. Explore (Research & Seeking Options): Invite other perspectives, examine systemic conditions and consider alternative explanations.

5. Act (Experimentation & Implementation): Make a considered intervention or run a small experiment.

6. Reflect (Evaluation & Analysis): Observe the consequences, examine what has changed and revise your understanding.

An example: rebuilding trust after a failed transformation

A digital transformation has missed several milestones. Senior leaders blame poor execution, while employees complain about unrealistic deadlines and insufficient consultation.

Rather than immediately launching a performance review, the executive team begins with inquiry.

First, it separates observations from interpretations: which milestones were missed, what happened and what is still unknown?

Second, it explores how the situation is experienced by different groups.

Third, it examines the assumptions embedded in the original plan, including beliefs about staff capacity, the complexity of the technology and the readiness of the organisation.

Fourth, it considers whether the failure reflects execution problems, unrealistic expectations, insufficient resources or several interacting factors.

Finally, the team tests a revised approach, collects feedback and examines what the experiment reveals.

The result is not indecision. It is action informed by a more adequate understanding of the situation.

8. Leadership development begins with the development of the observer

A deeper implication of phenomenology is that leadership development cannot be confined to acquiring new skills and techniques.

Leaders also need to examine the ways they habitually experience and interpret the world.

Two leaders may learn the same feedback model, strategic framework or communication technique. Yet one may use it to confirm existing assumptions, while the other uses it to question those assumptions and discover something new.

The difference lies partly in the quality of their attention and their willingness to examine how they make meaning.

This connects with developmental approaches that invite leaders to recognise their own assumptions, rather than simply operate more effectively within them. Torbert’s action inquiry, for example, encourages attention to the relationship between first-person awareness, second-person dialogue, third-person observation and the wider systems in which action takes place.

Husserl’s contribution is more foundational: he reminds us to investigate how meaning arises in experience before treating our interpretation as self-evident.

For leadership development and coaching supervision, this creates a powerful reflective question:

What am I not seeing because of the way I am accustomed to seeing?

It invites leaders to recognise that they are not detached observers of organisational reality. They participate in the relationships, conversations and actions through which that reality is continually interpreted and shaped.

Conclusion: learning to see differently

Husserl’s phenomenology offers no shortcut to leadership wisdom. It offers something more fundamental: a discipline for becoming more aware of experience, more careful about interpretation and more open to the perspectives of others.

In uncertain and complex environments, leaders will inevitably act before every ambiguity has been resolved. The challenge is not to eliminate interpretation or uncertainty, but to recognise their presence and remain willing to learn.

Leaders who develop this capacity can become less attached to their first explanation, more attentive to the lived experiences of others and more capable of testing their assumptions against evidence and consequences.

The ultimate value of phenomenological inquiry is not simply that leaders become more reflective. It is that reflection changes how they listen, decide, relate and act.

Perhaps the most important leadership question is not only, “What should I do?” but also, “How have I come to see this situation in the way I do — and what might become possible if I learned to see it differently?”

Reference

  • Husserl, E. (2025). Ideas: general Introduction to Pure Phenomenology, Andrii Ponomarenko, Ukraine-Kyiv.


Leave a Reply